Coming soon on French TV (end of March-"France 2" Channel), a new Reality show in which French people are acting as real Torturers with Electricity. Not less than 80% of the Candidates, discovering at the end of the Game only, that the Torture was not real but the victim an actor, shouting although like a real Guantanamo prisoner. Christophe Nick who had the idea of this program wanted to underline the slippery slope of some Reality-shows that -he said- one can see overseas, notabily in Great-Britain.
This allows me to continue two rather different ideas that I am arguing about on this weblog since (too) many years after French philosopher Simona Weil and her main work on socialism dictatorship and oppression (more useful than Huxley, less acurate than Karl Marx).
- First idea: Compared with today Politics, former Nazism was just more frank, what probably partly made its faster End. Probably it is special French ability to recognize frankness? Of course, I am able to prove to anybody against it that Hitler's liberalism is nothing else than ordinary liberalism, regarding to Metaphysics, Science or Economics on which nazism is based on.
- Second idea: Special today hypocrisy is made by the Press and the Networks under the control of the Industry (with no exception in France). With football, Olympic Games or idiotic TV-series, they maintain people in their stupidity.
Due to our virtual/judiciary Culture that is condemning criminal intentions for prevention, candidates of this Reality-Fake Show should be indicted, not thanked by Christophe Nick as they are! A Jewish woman who played the torturer in the Game does explain that she did not understand why her grand-parents did not refuse to have a yellow star on their clothes. Stupidity is for sure part of the crimes of nazism little civil servants!
Intention of committing a crime should be condemned here as an example as it is usually. Or the French Channel and Christophe Nick should be instead! It sounds maybe crazy. But ask yourself if the law is not the craziest. Listen to this: Not prosecuting those people or the Channel would be justified by the same reason that made the Candidates act like real torturers, obeying to the order of the Game Master. Because they believed TV is benefiting of an Injustice!
*
But fight of Christophe Nick against crazy TV-Shows only sounds hypocrit. Who needs to be told that these programs are indecent? More indecent are the programs about Serial Killers and criminal inquieries on State French Channels (with fewer commercials) made either for frightening weak people or for whiting the Politics and the Capitalist Society that is making those crazy murderers. Fascination for Death is the same than paederastic fascination for Sex. There is no real porn without blood and death, or sometimes torture.
Therefore Christophe Nick's scientific basis is wrong. He is based on Milgram's sociology studies to explain that 80% of the people would commit acts of torture as those candidates. But Sociology is not a Science, this is the religion of a Socialist State or Politics! I could reply Mr Nick that no one of my friends would be agree to participate in a TV-Show! He is starting from the fact that every French people is venal or narcissic.
TV is Propaganda, not only TV-shows. We had recently the proof of it in the general agreement of the US-Citizens for Irak's invasion though lots of US-Citizens do not even know where Irak is located. French example is better proof because French people were first time manipulated by TV FOR Irak invasion, and a few years after AGAINST.
Problem of Sociology seen as a Science is not as anodyne because Sociology is the heart of darwinism and Nazism already, which has a physiocratic background as every kind of liberalism (For marxist science, statistics are against History; especially Milgram's use of statistics.)
(TO BE CONTINUED)
Commentaires
You have some problems with identification... Simona Weil wasn't a French philosopher, she was a Jewish philosopher. The fact that she lived in France and wrote in French doesn't change her Jewish essence.
If you remember I recommended you to read Berdyaev. A lot of things told by Simona Weil had been told by him before her.
What she said about nazism and politics, what she would say about TV-shows, football, Olympic games if she lived up to nowdays are just banalities a la J. de Maistre. The most important thing told by her is that evil when it meets suffering turns into suffering. Physics. "France has been conquered by Nazi but Indochina will be released". Remember? Without Stalin there would be no Hitler... Physics.
Butcher and victim, evil and suffering... They always go together... And will go. Your Christophe Nick isn't a fool...
Identity is like mathematics for a marxist like me: nothing real in it, just ghosts. We know for sure that Simona Weil did not want to believe in Jewish identity. 'Identity' is the most subjective idea, and if you deny Simona herself to choose her own, you are not far away to understand the use of mathematics in modern dictatorship like Hitler's one or USA-today.
(Far away from Simona Weil is Joseph de Maistre Christian free masonic idea because you can find in Simona Weil some explanations that enable to understand that this kind of Christian free masonic idea is pure Satanism.)
You even know what mathematics means... Really? Even G. Weyl (not Weil) didn't know! As he said God exists since mathematics is consistent, and the Devil exists since its consistency cannot be proved.
By the way, Simona Weil was a good mathematicians. Like her brother...
You are not a good reader. Simona Weil not only was continuing the Greek tradition against Mathematics but even wrote that Max Planck's mathematics (based on foolish Helmholtz tricks) are PURE BULLSHIT.
Principle of Mathematics, as it is closer to religion than Science demands the ignorance that you are talking about; of course no real Scientist is proud as stupid Riemann was too, to ignore what his own principles are. Mathematician does not understand Mathematics more than the Insecta do understand the Entomology!
Are you from Texas or what?
Thank you. In response I can say that you're a bad reader too. Literally (in contrast to me, a person from Texas, you can read her in French). Plus you're a narrow-minded interpretator of what you've read.... As a French reader you should evaluate a mathematical exactness of her language, a creation of her own concentrated terms... Her thoughts are formed as a theorem proving...
So please don't be a cowboy, you like just your own cow but there are a lot of other ones!
It's like you said that she didn't believe in her Jewish identity... First, it's not true. Second, if it was so, she would stop to be Jewish in that case? If she was French, she would choose dancing cancan instead of eating starvation rations...
- Identity is for a Christian like me something Satanic. It is the idea of somebody belonging to his country or 'nation'. Due to the comparison between the earth and a mother, a matrix, identity is probably a paederastic idea. It was recently illustrated by nazism (see for instance Nietzsche's paederastic philosophy).
- United Nations are condemned to Hell in saint John's Revelation. Therefore this is Judas' faith.
As Simona Weil was seeing the 'Society' as the most Satanic thing from the Christian Gospels, she is as far away from "identity idea" than she is away from mathematics.
- Because she hated Jewish religion, Simona Weil was condemned a few years ago by an idiotic Yankee called Francis Kaplan... to be Jewish again! How can you think we can read this kind of process in France but as a bad joke? Notice that your 'Jewish identity' did not even existed yet when Simona Weil died. To be modern most of Jewish people were pulling their Jewish religion away before WWII in Europa.
Again : Do not make people that Jewish people are all the same!
J'adore votre site, merci à vous de partager ces idées et je "plussoie" complètement ce point de vue. Permettez-moi d'insister, votre blog est très bon, je viens d'ailleurs de twitter ce billet (si jamais ça peut vous aider)... Désolé pour les éventuelles fautes, n'étant en effet pas francophone, j'ai utilisé Google Translate.